Jay Jaffe FanGraphs Chat – 6/18/24

Jay Jaffe: Tomorrow I’ll have one thing on the Yankees and Anthony Rizzo’s damaged arm. Accidents have reduce into my checklist of gamers I used to be planning on checking into; a few of these might need to attend till after I return. We’ll see

MP: Kelenic going to get an article quickly about turning his season round? Only a sizzling streak or do you assume a few of this may stick?

Jay Jaffe: Kelenic is 24 years outdated, and whereas that’s too younger to jot down off, a fast take a look at his splits and traits tells me to not get very enthusiastic about two sizzling weeks. Sure, he’s hitting the ball tougher however not that tough, he’s additionally chasing greater than you’d like, and in contrast to final 12 months, he’s actually struggling in opposition to lefties.

Part 34: Will Fangraphs ever do an Orioles prime prospects checklist this 12 months?

Jay Jaffe: Assuming they don’t secede from Main League Baseball, I’d assume so, however I don’t make the schedule. I think about they’re coming quickly – clearly, it’s a deep system with numerous fascinating gamers who’re turning into extra related because the July 30 deadline approaches.

Matt VW: Most observers firstly of the season felt the Crimson Sox can be sellers on the deadline. Are they nonetheless on monitor to take action, or will they preserve pursuing a wild card berth in an effort to placate an more and more disaffected fan base?

Jay Jaffe: they’re three video games above .500 and a pair of.5 out of the third Wild Card spot, with the next-closest crew 2.5 video games in again of them. I believe in the event that they offered below these circumstances, the ensuing fury from Crimson Sox followers would make the Boston tea occasion look tame. Now, in the event that they lose floor, it’s a special story, and we’ve bought six weeks to see what unfolds.

Jay Jaffe: I do assume the Sox have made some first rate progress this 12 months. The rotation has been a pleasant shock, and a few of the kids — Duran, Abreu, Wong particularly — have been spectacular, as was Casas earlier than his damage. They’re shifting in the fitting path.

Francisco Lindor: 70 profession WAR…are you taking the over or the below?

Jay Jaffe: I’ll take the below however not by a lot — I wish to see a bit extra consistency with the bat. He’s dug himself some early holes on the offensive facet and so his slash strains are unremarkable. however man, he’s a formidable defender. I believe he’s a HOFer within the making.

KC Ache: Ben Rice bought the decision and appears fairly universally meh on scouting reviews.  40s and like a 35-40 grade total. Current efficiency change any of that?

Jay Jaffe: Verify in tomorrow. Eric hasn’t been wowed by him, particularly on the defensive facet, and his future in all probability isn’t at catcher (he’s permitting about 2 SB per recreation and has a ridiculously low  CS%). Maybe the bat progresses extra rapidly if he sheds the instruments of ignorance.

Jay Jaffe: (I’m hoping to get extra enter from Eric for the Rizzo piece)

Tigers fan: Which present participant do you assume could have the best HOF profession/legacy?  Trout, Ohtani, Choose Soto and so on.?

Jay Jaffe: I believe all 4 of these guys are going to wind up in Cooperstown with spectacular however very totally different legacies. Trout handed the JAWS common for middle fielders earlier than his twenty seventh birthday (https://blogs.fangraphs.com/mike-trout-is-now-an-average-hall-of-famer…). Ohtani is a two-way participant like we’ve by no means seen earlier than. Choose’s energy is unimaginable, as is Soto’s batting eye. If Ohtani can return to pitching nicely whereas nonetheless hitting nicely, I believe he’s the reply however I believe that a method or one other  we’ll be speaking about all of those guys 50 years from now (possibly not me, as I’ll be 104 years outdated).

Oil Can Boyd: As a observe up, he’s one Andrew on of 13 gamers in MLB historical past to have 2,000 Hits, 400 Doubles, 45 Triples, 300 HR, 200 SB.

Oil Can Boyd: Simply seen that Cutch has the identical variety of profession ho.srz as Edgar Martinez. As a Pirates fan, I all the time noticed him as a Corridor of Very Good participant, however squinting, I do see a HOF resume.

Jay Jaffe: whoops, bought these two out of order .Sorry, no, Andrew McCutchen doesn’t have a powerful case for the Corridor neither is he a very good comp for Edgar. Edgar owns a profession 147 OPS+ and 68.4 WAR, and that’s factoring in his time at DH. Cutch owns a 127 OPS+ and 49.3 WAR, and it doesn’t appear like he’s gonna get to 55 not to mention 68. It’s a really good profession however he hasn’t actually been an above-average participant constantly in his 30s, and the junk-drawer assortment of stats you cited isn’t going to sway anybody. Who cares about 45 triples?

2016? I Hardly Keep in mind ‘Em: Strictly talking, is it doable that the Cubs roster transferred the “Billy Goat Curse” onto themselves instead of the franchise? Joking apart, arduous pressed to consider a extra outstanding crew the place the collective core (Bryant, Rizzo, Baez) light from its peak and/or did not reside as much as its promise so prominently – are there every other instances in your thoughts that examine?

Jay Jaffe: I can’t consider an analogous case offhand, which isn’t to say that there aren’t comps. Oddly sufficient I believe one in all my colleagues is contemplating a take a look at these three Cubs’ arcs. You’ll understand it once you see it.

C-Low: Any cause why you didn’t write in regards to the Os dropping Bradish, possible for the 12 months? I’ve seen plenty of damage articles however not even a sentence about all of the Orioles pitching accidents.

Jay Jaffe: I wrote in regards to the Bradish and Means accidents in February and was targeted elsewhere when each went down extra not too long ago, although I anticipated we’d cowl it. Apparently it slipped by way of the cracks. I’m positive we’ll test in on the Orioles’ rotation sooner or later within the not-too-distant future as a result of clearly they’ll be available in the market for assist.

DJ Tofu: Is it doable to say roughly how a lot WAR a participant can acquire in WAR from a particular PA, in comparison with making an out? e.g. if Participant A presently has 2.0 WAR and in at this time’s recreation he had 1 HR, 1BB and in addition made 2 outs, is there a fast solution to get his WAR tomorrow? Thanks.

Jay Jaffe: Type of… In case you go to our leaderboards web page and select “Stay Stats — At present” from the Splits dropdown you may see the entire hitters’ performances, however the WARs solely go to 1 decimal and that might not be superb sufficient since few gamers enhance their WARs even by .1 in a given day. You can too select “Stay Stats — Full Season” and get the operating whole, then examine it to the beforehand printed model.

Damaged Bat: Padres and get a SP… I skinny Padres have to be burning the midnight oil in making an attempt to find out seize a Tier 1 SP. The long run contracts bind sending a positional mlb participant apart from Kim. However what about Estrada and possibly a prospect say for Lugo or somebody like that. Does Estrada now have perceived worth?

Jay Jaffe: The Royals are contenders in order that they’re not buying and selling Lugo. Names I’d assume might be out there would come with Crochet, Flaherty, Severino (if the Mets can’t maintain this surge), Quantrill, possibly Luzardo. As for the idea of turning Estrada into one thing extra priceless on the deadline, this text might be relevant:

https://blogs.fangraphs.com/no-you-cant-trade-your-newfound-reliever-f…

Jay Jaffe: You’re asking about acquiring prepared rotation assist as an alternative of a prospect, so it’s not fairly parallel, however most groups have relievers who might plausibly come out nowhere to go on a 25-inning sizzling streak, so no one is giving up enormous worth for these of another crew.

Searching for Options: Pricey Professor Jaffe, what’s your finest present thought to assist jumpstart the completely depressing offensive atmosphere within the recreation proper now?

Jay Jaffe: Um, how about banning the shift? Oh, they tried that?? Welp.

I believe the 2 solutions which are most believable are to monkey with the strike zone itself, a time-honored custom (see 1968-69, for instance) and to extra transparently juice up the baseball.  Except you’re ready for an onslaught of house runs, I believe you’d must pair the latter with a rise in fence heights — possibly to a minimal peak of X ft, or having a sure % of the fences in every ballpark meet that customary — which might preserve extra balls in play however make extra-base hits extra frequent.

AL Central Casting: To your data, has anybody analyzed the variety of damaged bats over the course of baseball historical past? Is that this even do-able with out watching each recreation? I assume they had been much less frequent the farther again you go (heavier bats with a special form and pitchers didn’t throw as arduous), however what different components would there be? Is it simply me or had been there extra damaged bats 10-20 years in the past?

Jay Jaffe: The US Forest Service even bought in on it!

Jason N: Is Tatis getting again on a HoF monitor?

Jay Jaffe: He’s hitting higher than final 12 months however I don’t assume we will say it’s sufficient to place him again on monitor after simply a few months of improved manufacturing. Moreover, the larger problem will probably be whether or not BBWAA voters forgive his PED suspension, which is one thing we now have but to see the required 75% supermajority do for any participant who has been suspended. Till that occurs – and I wouldn’t maintain my breath, because the query now pivots round A-Rod — there isn’t a lot to speak about.

Showbusiness77: Hello Jay … thanks for the chat. Do you assume Brent Rooker’s early season success was a mirage? Do we predict he finds his manner out of this horrible stoop to be some X% of the place he was?

Jay Jaffe: Rooker had a pleasant breakout final 12 months and is definitely forward of that by way of his wRC+, SLG, and Statcast numbers. I wouldn’t quit on him.

Playing cards fan: I see numerous concepts about rising SP workloads and decreasing the parade of relievers (finagle DH utilization, make relievers face greater than 3 batters, kill the AAA shuttle and so on ).  What would you do to extend the position of the SP?

Jay Jaffe: Trim the variety of pitchers on the roster to 12, enhance the obligatory variety of batters confronted for a reliever (or an opener, for that matter) to 4 or 5, and impose tougher limits on the quantity of churn that occurs on rosters almost about relievers being shuttled to Triple-A and again

RynoatSecond: Jay, with the automated strike zone an inevitability sooner or later, do you assume MLB will take the chance to decrease the efficient strike zone, thereby dis-incentivizing the excessive’s 90 fastball that’s unhittable up there? The sport is faster however I nonetheless don’t assume they’ve mounted the core problem of the sport which is sufficient balls in play.

Jay Jaffe: I believe that even when we get the problem system model of ABS — which appears to be extra possible than the every-pitch model as gamers and groups drastically want it — we’ll see some rejiggering of the strike zone, and that would assist deal with the problem [late note: The Athletic’s Jayson Stark reports that the ABS system in Triple-A is now only going to be a challenge system]

Philly Steve: Are the 2024 Phillies the very best crew in fashionable historical past? Looks like a very good shot that Harper, Turner, Schwarber, Nola and Wheeler all make it into Cooperstown.

Jay Jaffe: Hold your pants on, Steve. Harper is more and more prone to wind up in Cooperstown, and Nola in all probability has the very best shot of any pitcher this facet of Gerrit Cole, however Wheeler bought a late begin and goes to have to stay exceptionally sturdy and efficient, and neither Turner nor Schwarber are on HOF tracks statistically; the latter’s finest season by bWAR is 3.2, and his next-best is 2.3. Good luck with that.

Jake Rogers Appreciator: Appreciated the Flaherty article! I really feel like his bounceback has gone a bit below the radar given how superior Skubal has been. You talked about on the finish he’s a very good commerce or extension candidate, what would you do with him if you happen to had been in cost in Detroit?

Jay Jaffe: Glad you loved the piece. He’s clearly taken to working with the present coaches so I believe if he’s open to an extension I’d attempt to re-sign him.

MH: How astonishing is it that Brandon Belt has not discovered a brand new crew but?

Jay Jaffe: It’s a little bit of a shock however he’s a restricted participant, as a DH who might often play first. Even given final 12 months’s spectacular wRC+, he didn’t hit the ball tremendously arduous, and so he was manner forward of his Statcast anticipated numbers, plus his strikeout charge spiked, I doubt he hasn’t had *any* presents, however the query of cash and pathway to common taking part in time might have been points that prevented him from signing. Not everyone is prepared to come back to camp on a minor league deal or, at this stage, spend a month driving the buses or in prolonged spring coaching as a way to attempt to justify a roster spot.

Visitor: You jinxed Jo Adell! ; )
It could seem these beneficial properties from the article have dissipated. Any hope left in addition to a change of surroundings and/or a miracle?

Jay Jaffe: Ha! Ouch. Adell appeared to have adjusted however the league adjusted again. Hopefully he can nonetheless name upon that temporary success, however I do surprise the place his head have to be at given his current numbers.

Crimson sox fan: The preliminary reviews had Breslow> Bloom.  How does it look to you now?

Jay Jaffe: Breslow >>> Bloom

Ben: With Means/Bradish out, how lots of the beginning pitchers that the Orioles have left are official playoff starters. Corbin Burnes, Grayson Rodriguez and???

Jay Jaffe: Cole Irwin might be OK as a fourth starter on a brief leash however they clearly want yet one more good pitcher within the combine to go along with these two.

Nick: Good article on Flaherty!                     How do you eat baseball throughout the season? Do you deal with one recreation? Have a number of screens? All the time curious to listen to how the analysts / writers watch the video games

Jay Jaffe: on most nights, if I’m watching I are inclined to default to Yankees or Mets video games within the 7 pm slot and/or Dodgers video games within the 10 pm slot, then flip round if these video games are lopsided or I do know I’m writing about any individual on one other crew. Generally meaning going again the subsequent day and watching segments of an archived recreation to get a really feel for what was occurring in a giant inning or with an damage or one thing. It varies.

Reds Enjoyer: Thanks as all the time for the chat Jay. How a lot of the blame for the Cubs season to this point does Jed Hoyer deserve? From the skin trying in, it appears to be like extra like they’ve been victims of unexpected regression (e.g. Dansby, Alzolay) than precise poor roster development.

Jay Jaffe: A few of the blame has to fall on the gamers. I’m unsure what to make of Swanson and Hoerner struggling so badly. The rotation has been good, and the acquisition of Michael Busch is holding up nicely. Bellinger has been unremarkable however he’s hardly the most important drawback. I’ve by no means been satisfied about Morel as greater than a stopgap, and the bullpen is a fright. So, a few of the blame has to fall on Hoyer and a few on Counsell as nicely, however I don’t assume there’s a single factor you may level to and say THIS is the reason for their issues.

Visitor: You assume Walker Buehler can get again heading in the right direction this season?

Jay Jaffe: The speed is there, however the stuff is down and so is the coommand. I believe it’s going to take a while for him to determine what works now versus what labored 2018-22.

Correa: Correa is having a fantastic 12 months and even higher previous few weeks.  He will get misplaced within the shuffle of wonderful AL SS however what are your ideas on his HOF path?

Jay Jaffe: Hoping to jot down about him quickly. I nonetheless assume he’s in good condition HOFwise, particularly if this sizzling streak heralds a return to his earlier degree of efficiency

KC Ache: Why are so many groups (it appears, def not the Padres) apprehensive to make strikes early vs deadline?  Flaherty aggravated one thing already and youd assume their want of bats, plus surplus of arms Madden, Manning, Jobe, and so on. a transfer can be accomplished now vs playing on 6 weeks.  Plus, didnt the Tigers do that with Fuller (Fullmer?)), Boyd, after which botch the touchdown with ERod and Lange final 12 months?

Jay Jaffe: Primarily as a result of no one needs to look dumb by making a commerce too early and feeling like they overspent as patrons or undersold as sellers. So the timing issues — and I believe most groups are going to attend so long as they will earlier than convincing themselves (and possession) that they’re really out of it. Let’s not overlook that the excessive price of promoting now features a main PR hit that may have multiyear ramifications so far as ticket gross sales and such.

Tjf167: Given what number of “unhealthy” selections are already within the HOF, the place would you set the profession WAR line at for there simply not being an argument for letting guys kn

Jay Jaffe: Apart from catchers, relievers, and mid-career gamers, I don’t assume we now have a lot to debate till a man hits about 50 WAR.

Nate: Is Aaron Choose the man that possible breaks by way of the Rule of two,000 (hits) with the BBWAA?  Or do you see anybody else on the market that may get there sooner with the BBWAA?

Jay Jaffe: I believe Andruw Jones or Chase Utley might be those to topple the Rule of two,000 lengthy earlier than Choose retires. And in the event that they don’t, Buster Posey will.

Booney: Do you worth all parts of WAR equally (though, definitionally, that is the purpose)? Marcus Semien is making an fascinating late profession HOF case, but even when he will get to 60 or so profession WAR, a part of me wonders how is total resume will probably be considered if he continues to rack up plenty of that from the defensive facet. He’s on tempo to have one other ~6 WAR 12 months however with a somewhat unremarkable .750-ish OPS and a heavy contribution from dWAR

Jay Jaffe: I all the time wish to know a number of defensive measures if doable, even when they’re contradictory. I believe most voters are tougher to persuade than I’m almost about defensive worth which is why a shorter profession/increased peak man like Utley, Andruw, or Semien might have a more durable time breaking by way of.

Tjf167: The mid 80s Yankees weren’t even capable of make the playoffs with apex Rickey Henderson, Winfield and Mattingly. Simply the worst waste of a core. Trout/Ohtani up there although.

Jay Jaffe: Trout and Ohtani have by no means been surrounded by sufficient good gamers however yeah these Yankees groups had been actually disappointing given the entire expertise they squandered.

Visitor: however enhance SP innings and lower SP accidents

Jay Jaffe: If I knew the reply to this I wouldn’t be chatting right here, alas.

KJ: What’s your go to put for oysters in/round Wellfleet?

Jay Jaffe: Mac’s Shack might be my prime spot for oysters (ran right into a well-known baseball author there final night time!). I had them a pair nights in the past at Winslow Tavern they usually had been tasty however had a bit too many shell fragments for me to take pleasure in them to the max — and in an space the place many of the oysters are of the identical selection, the supply issues.

Truro native: love the outer cape shout out!!!!

Jay Jaffe: My favourite Cape restaurant is Blackfish in Truro! Headed there later this week!

glyonstribe: Lindor’s bought the hype and the contract, however Ramirez is forward in most stats.  Who would you’re taking for the remainder of their careers?

Jay Jaffe: Some individuals have a tendency to speak about Lindor as if his protection doesn’t matter. It’s not an either-or proposition the place one can simply examine his offensive numbers to a slugging third baseman and contemplate the matter settled. If I’m working with their present contracts I’d somewhat have the cheaper Ramirez, positive, since they’re vaguely comparable in worth, but when I wanted extra protection I might do fairly nicely with Lindor at quick.

Visitor: Jay do you assume there will probably be a pull again with sports activities betting partnerships with MLB given the leagues historical past with playing and the problems which have already appeared?

Jay Jaffe: I ****ing hope so.

Jay Jaffe: okay of us, that’s it for me this week — and doubtless will probably be as much as my neck in sandcastles and oysters subsequent week. Thanks a lot for stopping by, and keep cool!